ok ill start from the bottom up..
sky's - i like it, but yes that font at the bottom.. the 'and friends' is kinda meh.. it just feels like it doesnt quite belong. Now, i do think the Captain America font works. hm.. maybe if it continued into the 'and friends' part, with a slightly smaller size, it could work better..? by no means, am i an expert.. but i think more aesthetically pleasing for me.
ink - meh, its ok.. couldve tightened up a couple areas.. maybe added some more complimentary colors, to kind of offset the yellow. its a lot yellow.. hah! there is a spot around the bridge of his nose that should be definitely toned down alot, to pull it all together.. gives me a feel of inconsistency, and throws me off a bit. it needs a border also. clearly, ive been out the game for a minute.
ya border, that should be like sig noob rule 101. maybe, not in every case.. but this one wouldve worked out here.
pigspig76 - first of all, that wisdom!
love the use of scripture here. tbh, i starred at pigs for the longest because there is so much to unpack. ive absolutely nothing negative to point out, accept maybe the reason it didnt get my vote was because it was so busy... which, if it wasnt.. then it wouldnt be the same. but yea, i was stuck in all the symbolism and i probably shouldve voted for this one as it really made the most impact on me..
itwas a curious blend of so much that kind of gave it a unique feel alltogether.. well done, pigs, excellent!
skelz - this got my vote. what can i say, dude is an OG. this is like the standard. proper proportions, centered, the lighting, the color scheme, the feeling that it gives off, the font works and it has a border! he sets the bar high my friends!